Customer Reviews
What You Need To Know
PREFACE
When I decided
to replace my old standard Dell keyboard, I opted for an illuminated
one. I settled on a choice of three, reading virtually every rating on
the Cyborg P17UK and Logitech's G11 & G15 on several sites before
finally selecting the Cyborg.
I use the Windows XP- 32 bit
operating system. I am not a gamer anymore; but am an extensive user of
productivity software and developer of sophisticated macros including
using VBA and SQL, especially for MircoSoft Office products. I also use
PhotoShop & Corel Draw as well as some audio editing software, and
do some web programming with Java and HTML. I am not a touch typist, but
no slouch either, and I do a lot of writing. So understand, my
recommendations are from this perspective.
RECOMMENDATION:
In
my opinion (IMAO), this is a sturdy, high quality board. Like many, I
was torn between the G11, G15 and the Cyborg. All are roughly equivalent
and, depending upon your needs, will work well. I chose the Cyborg
because I didn't need or think the G15's LCD panel useful, and perhaps a
bit fragile; and because I'm not impressed with Logitech- ok equipment,
but not certainly top-of-the-line. However, you should be satisfied
with any of these. I also found the non-gaming boards seem not to be as
durable as these three.
The four star rating is based on poor
documentation, navigation on the website is somewhat confusing, other
reviewers report support problems with Saitek (although I have found
this not to be the case), and because I think many will find
installation and programming a bit sophisticated- not hard for anyone
with any savvy at all, but certainly more difficult than it needs to be.
Note Saitek has updated their on-line manuals and software which makes
installation much easier and less time consuming.
SPECIFICATIONS:
Quality
of Construction: (Excellent)- The Cyborg is made of the same extruded
plastic material as most, if not all keyboards. The WASD and arrow keys
are aluminum clad for extra wear, and all keys are laser etched.
System
Requirements: Windows XP, XP 64-bit or Vista
Dimensions: 21.5" W
x 9.5" D x 1.5"H
Connection: one USB 2.0 port
Ports:
Microphone, audio, and one USB- all are pass-through; that is, the ports
are really extension connectors that plug into your computer
---------------------------------------------
Keyboard
Design: Gaming Series
Illuminated: Yes- white, green, amber,
red, & dark red; no blue
Illumination levels: 4- Off, Dim,
Medium, Bright, Intense; the specs say only three but perhaps I have a
newer model with a brighter intensity
Keys (Number of): 118
(including a standard 104 layout with keypad)
Multimedia Keys:
Yes
Internet Keys: No
-----------------------------------------------------
Programmable
Keys: (Cyborg or "C" keys)
Physical: 12, each with three
possible shiftstates: Unshifted, Shift +, and a third shiftstate using
one of the "C" keys (instead of Alt+ or Ctrl+) as a state shifter
Virtual:
33 (12 keys x 3 states = 36 less 3 lost for the "C" key used as the
third shiftstate shifter)
Program Code: SST (Saitek Smart
Technology)
---------------------------------------------------------
Cordless/Wireless:
No
Mouse Included: No
Warranty Terms: Parts and Labor- 2
years
CONSIDERATIONS:
Installation isn't simple; there
will most likely be issues and it will take some time. Note this can be
made substantially easier by following the advice provided below.
This
keyboard uses a USB port; the on-board port will use a second (but
since its pass-through, there's only a net use of 1 port)
The USB
version is whatever it is plugged into on the computer (most probably
2.0); Logitech's G11/15 uses 1.1 (much slower)
Keyboard is wider
(21.5") than the 18" `standard'; you may want to check your physical
space.
Keys are a bit smaller than standard- most notably the
Escape & "F" keys-but I don't find this to be a problem at all.
The
keys are quiet but not silent- see advice below if you want or need
key-click.
This may be a newer model as I have noticed some
different features than those listed or mentioned by other reviewers.
Certainly the programming software has been updated, much easier to use,
and includes a new SST programming help manual.
There are two
types of software used by the keyboard: Drivers (there are 4), and the
programming software (Optional- used to program the "C" keys).
Programming
the "C" keys requires a little knowledge of macros.
The "C" keys
are keystroke not, strictly speaking, command programmable keys.
However, you can program hotkeys and emulate commands in many cases.
ADVICE:
If
you follow the advice below, you should have few problems in installing
and using the Cyborg keyboard, at least on the Windows XP Pro 32 bit
operating platform.
--------------------------------------------
After
ordering the Cyborg, register for the Saitek online forum [..]. The
process will take a day or so as Saitek checks for a legitimate e-mail
address and sends you an activation code (they report having porn
spamming problems). Registration is free.
Once registered on the
forum, download the following:
Updated drivers and software [Beta
2]([..]). Do not install, just save for future installation once you
receive your keyboard. Install this updated software instead of that
which comes with the keyboard.
The user manual that will come
with your new keyboard[..]
A better user manual albeit for a
different keyboard (but the setup is essentially the same) that includes
a troubleshooting section. [..]
SST (Saitek Smart Technology)
Guide if you plan to program the "C" keys [..]
----------------------------------------
When
installing the keyboard & software:
Disable USB Power
Management- refer to [..], Post #1, Solution 1.
Make sure you
logged on with administrator's rights or the drivers/software will not
install (the manual omits this).
Follow the installation guide
precisely- ALL drivers are required (including the "magic mouse"), but
you don't need the software unless you are going to program the "C" keys
(installation will give you a choice).
Use the newer (Beta 2)
version of the software/drivers downloaded previously instead of the CD
that comes with the keyboard.
I would advise against a USB/PS2
(keyboard port) adapter since the keyboard needs power from the USB port
to operate.
If you want to program commands, download a hotkey
manager utility such as EvoKey. I find HotKey Manager from [..] simpler
to use (both are freeware).
If the keys are too quiet for you,
install a utility that will give them a sound such as Noisy Keyboard
(freeware from:[..])
You could use this from your lap, but I'd
remove the wrist pad.
RESPONSE TO CRITICISMS:
Be sure to
remove the protective clear plastic covering over the touchpad and "C"
keys. This isn't mentioned in the manual but should be.
Slippery
keys: I haven't noticed my fingers slipping off the keys.
Shoddy
workmanship: Sounds to me like a quality control (QC) issue; especially
when a customer receives 2 "B" keys and no "V". I have had no hardware
issues.
No blue or white light: Mine has white light; is it a
deal breaker that there's no blue hue?
Illumination not bright
enough: I find it plenty bright, especially on white and light amber.
Dark red isn't as intense (but looks meaner), but then it's a dark
color. Also, I have four intensities.
Key Wear: This has been
reported in several different places; but the keys are extruded plastic
and shouldn't wear through any more than wearing the letters off a
regular key. One reviewer reports the keys were reengineered in response
to this difficulty (I haven't experienced this).
Only 12
Programmable Keys and 36 possible functions: Well, actually only 33 but I
can't imagine anyone needing more than that. If you really need 18
physical keys & 54 functions, get the other keyboard.
Gapped
Wrist Pad: I don't know why Saitek designed a gap in their wrist pad,
but its no problem for me; probably because I learned typing the old way
(wrists-up).
Cord to short: its a standard size cord- you could
get a USB extension if that's a problem.
Too Pricy: maybe, but
its within market prices of competitors and you know this up front.
Great keyboard that feels better than the g15
Overall I am quite happy with
this keyboard in comparison with the "new" g15. The keys are easier to
press and light up far more brightly than the g15. Being able to change
the color scheme in the gaming mode really looks awesome. One point I do
not like but most would is that in gaming mode the windows key press is
cut from the keyboard meaning even if you have it disabled via your
registry you cannot press the windows key which I use for skype,
ventrilo and teamspeak. Some may complain of the spacebar but it feels
fine except it feels as if it could become a sticky press down the line
but overall not a significant problem. I can also press more than 3 keys
at once and all the keystrokes will register in comparison with the
eclipse 2. Great for gamers and for people who type frequently.
Too Cool For School...
This keyboard is unbelievably
cool.
This is a standard US keyboard, with the key layout being
familiar to most. The keys are a standard height with a solid feel, as
opposed to low profile scissor keys which some say have a faster
response. In the end it is a matter of taste. This keyboard responds
well, and has a low noise level, which makes for a wonderful typing
experience.
This keyboard is bright, even in a well lighted room.
Cyborg is unique in the the ability to switch colors, zones and
brightness level. Of course, if you like blue, you might want a
different keyboard, since blue is not an option.
Having metal
keys seems to be a good idea, and while the keys wont break, more of the
typing force should transfer itself more easily to the plastic keyboard
underneath the keys, which could conceivably cause some damage. Of
course, when or if that damage does occur, I will either would have died
of old age, or would have bought a new keyboard, so I am not too
worried about that.
There are a few nice auxilliary features
worth mentioning. The keyboard has a mic/headphone input, and a usb
port, which might come in handy for a few folks. The standoffs, or
"feet" as I like to call them are the best I have seen on a keyboard,
with feet in the front and the back, and the back ones have two levels
of height adjustment.
The optional (as in non attached) handrest
is an interesting feature. The keyboard without the handrest is almost
unusable, since the front of the keyboard has a slope similar to Mount
Everest. The handrest itself is very functional, being able to slide it
out to two different levels to lay flatter or stick tighter to the
keyboard. The problem I have with the handrest (and the reason for the
four star rating) is the little gap in the middle. While this makes it
look quite cool, your poor right has to suspend itself over this gap,
while your left hand types in comfort. You would think this wouldn't
make a difference but it does. You can tell by sliding your right hand
over to the number pad. It's a big difference.
Now, sure this is a
"gaming" keyboard, so the bulk of the handrest is situated around the
"gaming" areas of the 'arrow keys' and the 'wasd keys' but certainly
even gamers need to type like a regular person every now and then. I
think I would have sacrificed the slightly cooler appearance of a
"notched" handrest for one that functioned as a handrest should.
Now,
there are a few things that could have been improved and might even be
considered goofy... like the stupid looking 'cyborg' icon, and the
inability to select an entirely 'monochromatic' lighting scheme. While
the keyboard itself lights up in the colors you choose, they touch panel
at the top stays green and red regardless. While this scheme looks fine
in some settings, it increases the gaudiness of a keyboard that already
has a striking design, and it would have looked kinda classy to have
all red or all green lights as an option.
The cyborg icon makes
me feel as if I have bought a control panel to a toy laser gun. To go
along with the icon they need a button which spoke something in a
mechanical voice if pressed like "Cyborg patrol officer reporting for
duty, sir..."
This keyboard might not be the best keyboard for
the heavy duty typist. But, if you are looking for something cool
looking to go with your cool computer, this keyboard is even cooler than
the pictures suggest. Try it out. You're left hand is gunna love it.
No comments:
Post a Comment